Searching for Alien Comets: BYU Researchers Create Guidebook to Aid in First Discovery

Treasure needs a map, vehicles need a manual, and, as it turns out, interstellar discoveries need a guidebook.

New research in Astrophysical Journal is acting as that guidebook to aid in the discovery of interstellar comets—comets from other solar systems. These “alien comets” are theorized to exist, but no one has actually found one yet. Observing them will uniquely help in understanding how planets are produced throughout the universe.

The new publication is an extension of the undergraduate senior thesis of Nathaniel Cook, former BYU student.

“It's already hard enough to discover comets from our own solar system, but because of the vast distances between the stars, interstellar comets are far more challenging,” co-author and professor Darin Ragozzine said. “Finding these sparse interstellar comets is hard because they need to be close to the Earth to be bright enough for detection, but the number of interstellar comets close enough to the Earth is ridiculously small on average.”

Interstellar comets would be an invaluable discovery because they would contain valuable information about the origin of other planetary systems. During the formation of a planetary system, billions of minor comets are also created and flung into space with so much energy that they escape from the pull of their own star. After this escape, these interstellar comets keep traveling in space—pieces of the planetary system they left behind.

“We’re excited because the benefit is huge,” lead author Nathaniel Cook said. “Currently, we don’t have any samples of material from planet formation around other stars. Zero.”

While there are hints of what other planets are made of, finding and studying an interstellar comet would give a close-up look at a real piece of another planetary system.

At first sight, an interstellar comet would look like any other comet. That’s where Cook’s guidebook helps out. It contains numerical simulations of what observing an interstellar comet would be like, including characteristics such as its fly-by path and size.

Interstellar comets won’t orbit the sun like comets from our solar system do. They aren’t held in place by our sun’s gravity—they instead enter and exit the solar system in an unbound path.

“Determining whether a comet is from another solar system is all about the orbit,” Cook said. “That’s the main difference, and it’s actually all you’re going to be able to actually measure until you point a more specific telescope at it.”

The most recent theory didn’t believe the discovery of interstellar comets would be possible, but these researchers are more optimistic. This new hope arises from making a more realistic guidebook about detecting interstellar comets. It focuses heavily on the upcoming Large Synoptic Survey Telescope (LSST) under construction in Chile.

When it begins operating around 2022, the LSST will scan the entire visible sky every few nights with its enormous camera. Combined with its size as one of the larger telescopes in the world, its ability to search the whole sky for very faint objects makes it ideal for a huge range of astrophysical studies, including the search for interstellar comets.

LSST would discover interstellar comets by comparing two pictures of the same spot of sky taken a few days apart. But this isn’t as simple as it sounds.

“Imagine taking a piece of paper with thousands of dots on it, then another almost identical piece of paper, and then someone asking you to tell which dot has moved,” Cook said. Algorithms for this search are used to discover comets and asteroids all the time, and this new guidebook helps astronomers know how to extend these techniques to include interstellar comets.

If astronomers identified a candidate with an unbound orbit characteristic of an interstellar comet among the LSST’s data, they’d then follow up with another telescope and use high-resolution spectroscopy to determine what the comet is made of and see if it differs from comets that come from our solar system.

This guidebook also estimates that anywhere from 0.01 to ten interstellar comets could be found during the LSST’s ten-year lifetime (compared to about 10,000 solar system comets). The researchers are also hopeful for what the discovery would mean for the entire astronomical field.

“Planetary formation is a hot topic in astronomy right now,” said Denise Stephens, BYU Astronomy Professor. “People want to know if other stars could have Earth-like planets and what else is out there. Interstellar comets would help us understand the whole range of different types of planets that might form.”

More Information on This Article

Article Source/Further Information

News and Events

Image for Mystery of Haumea's Formation Solved
BYU Physics and Astronomy student Benjamin Proudfoot recently published research in the prestigious journal Nature Communications that solves the mystery of the icy dwarf planet Haumea's formation.
Image for Debunking acoustics myths around the Saturn V
When the Saturn V rocket propelled man to the moon in July 1969, the blast from the rocket’s engines was tremendous. Marked by a dazzling display of flames and deafening noise, the monumental event gave rise to widespread claims that the acoustic force of the rocket melted concrete and ignited grass fires miles away. New research from BYU debunks this common myth.
Image for Dr. Aleksandr Mosenkov, new Astronomy faculty
Dr. Aleksandr Mosenkov, new faculty, looks forward to receiving some of the first data from the James Webb Space Telescope to study galaxy formation
Image for Sounding out the Deep: Traci Neilsen’s Trip to the North Atlantic
A recent research adventure took Dr. Traci Neilsen and two students to the North Atlantic Ocean. Neilsen, an associate professor of physics at BYU, and her team apply artificial intelligence to noises in the ocean to classify the seabed.
Image for Reveling in Uncertainty
Despite the inherent time constraints of engaging undergraduate and graduate students in research, Scott Bergeson enjoys teaching this “seek and find” principle to his students, a principle that has become his philosophy for life.
Image for BYU Acoustics Records Artemis Launch
A group of BYU students and professors gathered acoustical recordings of at the world’s most powerful rocket launch.
Image for Kent Gee Recognized by AIAA
Kent Gee is selected as Associate Fellow of American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics in their class of 2023
Image for West Mountain Observatory contributes to understand distant galaxy
BYU’s West Mountain Observatory was one of 37 ground-based telescopes throughout the world monitoring the active galaxy that is roughly 1 billion light years away.
Image for Dr. Tim Leishman retires from BYU
Dr. Leishman's time at BYU was filled with great teaching and profound mentoring
Image for Dr. John Colton: Table Tennis Champion
Dr. John Colton won the 2022 BYU intramural table tennis tournament